Top 100 Players of All-Time

By Position

Old Field 

by Bruce Grossberg
edited by Steve Orinick


Top Players / Teams

CATCHER
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS
27. Josh Gibson               786             18
33. Johnny Bench             655             24
37. Yogi Berra                  491             19
42. Mike Piazza                330             17
62. Roy Campanella          111               6
70. Mickey Cochrane          79              4
83. Buck Ewing                  45              2

FIRST BASE
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS

11. Lou Gehrig                 1239             25
20. Jimmie Foxx                937             25
43. Mark McGwire             322             12
47. Jeff Bagwell                 260             13
52. Johnny Mize                185               9
54. Hank Greenberg          168               8
59. Buck Leonard              128               5
68. Cap Anson                    82               3
74. Dan Brouthers               70               3
76. Eddie Murray                 66              3
80. Willie McCovey              53              3
85. Mule Suttles                  39              2
87. Frank Thomas                37              2

SECOND BASE
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS
13. Rogers Hornsby         1140            25
17. Eddie Collins             1049            25
22. Joe Morgan                879             23
23. Nap Lajoie                  846             24
46. Jackie Robinson          267             12
57. Charlie Gehringer        130              7
79. Bid McPhee                54              2
91. Roberto Alomar            28              2

SHORTSTOP
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS

  2. Honus Wagner           1626           25
38. Arky Vaughan              385           17
45. Cal Ripken                   292          15
51. Alex Rodriguez            186            9
58. Pop Lloyd                    129            5
71. Robin Yount                  77            4
81. George Davis                51            3
89. Ozzie Smith                  33            2

THIRD BASE
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS

15. Mike Schmidt            1195            25
30. Eddie Mathews           699             24
36. George Brett               595             24
69. Wade Boggs                80              5

LEFT FIELD
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS

  4. Ted Williams            1510            25
  8. Barry Bonds             1341            24
10. Stan Musial              1242            25
26. Rickey Henderson       812            22
48. Ed Delahanty              246            11
49. Carl Yastrzemski        234           12
55. Pete Rose                  135             6
60. Joe Jackson                125             5
88. Tim Raines                   35             2
90. Willie Stargell                29             2

CENTER FIELD
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS

  3. Willie Mays              1614            25
  5. Ty Cobb                   1491            25
  9. Tris Speaker             1291            25
12. Mickey Mantle           1195            25
25. Joe DiMaggio              841            23
32. Oscar Charleston        663             16
40. Ken Griffey Jr.             357            15
67. Duke Snider                 82              5
72. Turkey Stearnes           75              3

RIGHT FIELD
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS

  1. Babe Ruth                  1742           25
  7. Hank Aaron                1423           25
18. Frank Robinson            959           25
28. Mel Ott                         766           23
56. Reggie Jackson           131             8
61. Roberto Clemente        114            5
65. Al Kaline                       90             6
73. Tony Gwynn                  70             4
77. King Kelly                     60             2

PITCHER
RANK  - NAME            POINTS    MENTIONS

  6. Walter Johnson         1467            25
14. Lefty Grove                1105            23
16. Cy Young                  1062            25
19. Christy Mathewson      940            25
21. Grover C. Alexander     924             24
24. Roger Clemens            841             23
29. Tom Seaver                 722             24
31. Greg Maddux               697             23
34. Satchel Paige             624             18
35. Warren Spahn             600              24
39. Bob Feller                   359             16
41. Bob Gibson                 347             18
44. Kid Nichols                  320              14
50. Sandy Koufax              194               8
53. Steve Carlton              175               9
63. Randy Johnson            100               5
64. Carl Hubbell                  94               5
66. Martin Dihigo                 86               2
75. Whitey Ford                  66               4
78. Tim Keefe                     58               3
82. Pedro Martinez              45               3
84.  Smokey Joe Williams    44               3
86. John Clarkson                37               2

Top 100 Players / Best Teams

Page back / Back to top